When searching for the best eye highlighters, I look for options that brighten and open the eyes without creasing or fading during the day. The Thrive Causemetics Brilliant Eye Brightener stands out for its luminous finish and long-lasting wear. For those seeking versatile, multi-use options, the tarte Glow Wardrobe Palette offers a mix of shades for different looks. However, tradeoffs often involve choosing between highly pigmented formulas that may need blending or more subtle options that require multiple layers. Keep reading for a detailed breakdown of each product to find the best fit for your needs.
Turn your wind-down time into listening time
- Thousands of audiobooks, podcasts and originals
- Listen on your phone, tablet or Echo — also offline
- Cancel anytime
Key Takeaways
- The top picks combine blendability with long-lasting brightness, making them reliable throughout the day.
- Multi-use sticks offer convenience but sometimes lack the intensity of dedicated highlighters.
- Price varies widely, with some premium options delivering superior luminosity at a premium cost.
- Creamy textures generally blend better but can crease if not set properly, especially on mature skin.
- Color selection is key; cool tones suit brightening, while warmer shades add a subtle glow.
| eye highlighter | Type | Finish | Cruelty-Free |
|---|---|---|---|
| NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Jumbo | Eyeshadow, Eyeliner, Highlighter | Matte, Metallic | Yes |
| NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Jumbo | Highlighter Stick | Pearl | — |
| Thrive Causemetics Brilliant E | — | Shimmer | — |
| COLORGRAM Under Eye Highlighte | Highlighter & Contouring Stick | — | — |
| tarte Glow Wardrobe Highlighti | Face & Eye Palette | — | Yes |
| tarte Fake Awake Eye Highlight | Highlighter Pencil | — | Yes |
More Details on Our Top Picks
NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Jumbo Eye Pencil, Blendable Eyeshadow Stick & Eyeliner – Cottage Cheese (Silver)
This NYX Jumbo Eye Pencil stands out for its versatility, functioning equally well as an eyeshadow, eyeliner, and highlighter. Its smooth, creamy texture allows for vivid color payoff in both matte and metallic finishes, making it a flexible choice for those who want one product to do multiple jobs. Compared with the Thrive Causemetics option, it’s less specialized for highlighting but offers broader application across eyes and face. The tradeoff is that it may require sharpening for precise application and can smudge if not set properly, which could be a downside for those seeking long-lasting, smudge-proof results. This pick makes the most sense for makeup enthusiasts who want a multi-purpose product that’s easy to incorporate into their routine without sacrificing color intensity.
Pros:- Versatile use as eyeshadow, eyeliner, and highlighter
- Smooth application with vivid color payoff
- Available in matte and metallic finishes
- Cruelty-free and PETA certified
Cons:- May require sharpening for precise application
- Creamy texture might smudge if not set properly
Best for: Makeup lovers seeking a multi-use product that can serve as eyeshadow, eyeliner, and highlighter in one
Not ideal for: Users who prioritize long-lasting, crease-proof highlighters or need precise application without sharpening
- Color:Cottage Cheese (Silver)
- Type:Eyeshadow, Eyeliner, Highlighter
- Finish:Matte, Metallic
- Cruelty-Free:Yes
Our verdict“This product is best for those who want a flexible, all-in-one makeup stick that combines multiple functions with vibrant color.”
NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Jumbo Multi-Use Face Highlighter Stick – Vanilla Ice Cream
The NYX Jumbo Face Highlighter Stick in Vanilla Ice Cream is designed for quick, effortless highlighting with a pearl finish that builds easily. Its twist-up design offers convenience, eliminating the need for sharpening, unlike the NYX Eye Pencil. Compared to the Thrive Causemetics shimmer stick, it’s less hydrating and nourishing, but it excels in creating a luminous glow with minimal effort. Its six shades provide versatility, although the limited variety might not suit every skin tone, and layering can be necessary for an intense highlight. The product’s potential to break if dropped is a minor concern but worth noting. This highlighter makes sense for those who want a straightforward, quick-to-apply glow without fuss and prefer a twist-up stick for on-the-go use.
Pros:- Buildable, pearl-finish glow with one swipe
- Twist-up design for easy, sharpening-free application
- Infused with Jojoba Oil for smooth blending
- Available in 6 shades for versatility
Cons:- Limited shade range may not suit all skin tones
- May require layering for a more intense glow
- Potential for product to break if dropped
Best for: People looking for an easy, portable highlighter that offers a natural pearl glow in multiple shades
Not ideal for: Individuals needing highly pigmented or intensely luminous highlights or those with very dry skin that requires extra hydration
- Shade:Vanilla Ice Cream
- Type:Highlighter Stick
- Finish:Pearl
- Application:Cheeks, nose, face
- Formulation:Infused with Jojoba Oil
- Design:Twist-up stick
Our verdict“This highlighter is ideal for those who want a simple, portable product that delivers a natural luminous glow with minimal effort.”
Thrive Causemetics Brilliant Eye Brightener Eyeshadow Stick Champagne Shine
This Thrive Causemetics highlighter combines a luminous champagne shimmer with nourishing oils, making it a strong choice for those who want a brightening effect that also hydrates the delicate eye area. Its cream-to-powder formula offers a soft, diffused glow, comparable in ease of blending to the NYX Jumbo Stick but with a more luxurious, skin-friendly feel. The inclusion of Ring Light Technology results in a flattering, soft-focus effect, ideal for enhancing tired eyes. While it’s more expensive than standard eyeshadows and needs sharpening, its waterproof, crease-resistant finish ensures longevity. Compared with the NYX Eye Pencil, it’s less versatile as a multi-purpose tool but excels in delivering a luminous, anti-fatigue look. This product is best suited for those who want a high-quality, nourishing highlighter for special occasions or daily brightening.
Pros:- Multi-use product for eyes, cheeks, and lips
- Hydrating, nourishing formula with skin-loving oils
- Long-lasting, waterproof, and crease-resistant
- Soft, luminous champagne shimmer
Cons:- Requires sharpening for use
- Limited to shimmer finish in this variant
- More expensive than basic highlighters
Best for: Consumers seeking a hydrating, long-lasting, multi-use illuminating product for eyes and face
Not ideal for: Budget-conscious buyers or those who prefer a matte finish or very minimal product for quick touch-ups
- Finish:Shimmer
- Formulation:Cream-to-powder
- Waterproof:Yes
- Nourishing Ingredients:Macadamia seed oil, Meadowfoam seed oil
- Built-in Sharpener:Yes
Our verdict“This highlighter makes the most sense for those who prioritize a nourishing, radiant glow with long-lasting, waterproof wear in a versatile package.”
COLORGRAM Under Eye Highlighter Stick 02 Cool Tone
The COLORGRAM Under Eye Highlighter Stick is tailored for brightening and contouring with a silky-smooth, long-lasting formula. Its cool-toned shade is especially effective for neutralizing dullness and shadows under the eyes, making it a strong alternative to the more versatile Tarte Glow Wardrobe palette, which offers multiple shades but less targeted under-eye brightness. Its retractable design makes it highly portable, while the creamy texture blends seamlessly into the skin for a radiant, natural look. The main tradeoff is that it’s limited to cool tones, which might not suit warmer skin tones or those looking for a more natural or warm highlight. For quick, on-the-go brightening, this stick is a reliable choice for people who prefer a dedicated under-eye product.
Pros:- Silky-smooth application for a flawless finish
- Long-lasting and smudge-proof formula
- Compact, retractable design for portability
- Cruelty-free formulation
Cons:- Limited to cool tone shades
- May require blending for seamless look
Best for: Individuals seeking a dedicated, quick-application under-eye brightener in cool tones
Not ideal for: Warm skin tones or users who want a multi-shade palette or more variety in highlighters
- Color:Cool Tone
- Type:Highlighter & Contouring Stick
- Design:Retractable
Our verdict“This highlighter is ideal for those who want a dedicated, cool-toned under-eye brightener that stays put all day.”
tarte Glow Wardrobe Highlighting Eye & Cheek Palette
The Tarte Glow Wardrobe palette offers a compact, multi-shade solution for highlighting, sculpting, and eyeshadow. Its four silky, blendable shades provide a natural, lit-from-within glow suited for various skin tones, comparable to the versatility of the NYX Jumbo Eye Pencil but with a more curated selection. The palette’s lightweight texture ensures easy blending without fallout, and its vegan, cruelty-free ingredients appeal to eco-conscious consumers. However, its limited shade range means you might need additional products for more variety or specific looks. It’s less suited for those seeking highly pigmented or bold highlights, but perfect for creating soft, natural radiance quickly. This palette makes the most sense for users who want a portable, all-in-one highlighter and eyeshadow solution for everyday wear.
Pros:- Versatile all-in-one palette for face and eyes
- Silky, blendable texture for a natural glow
- Vegan and cruelty-free formulation
- Compact and easy to carry
Cons:- Limited to four shades, may require additional products for variety
- Potentially less suitable for very sensitive skin
Best for: Those seeking a versatile, compact palette for natural highlighting and eyeshadow in a single product
Not ideal for: Users who prefer highly pigmented or bold highlights or need extensive color variety
- Type:Face & Eye Palette
- Number of Shades:4
- Texture:Silky, lightweight
- Vegan:Yes
- Cruelty-Free:Yes
- Dermatologist Tested:Yes
Our verdict“This palette is perfect for those wanting a simple, multi-purpose product that delivers a soft, natural radiance for everyday looks.”
tarte Fake Awake Eye Highlight – Brightening Highlighter Pencil for Eyes & Brows, Longwear, Vegan & Cruelty-Free
The tarte Fake Awake Eye Highlight stands out for its long-lasting, waterproof formula that effectively brightens the inner corners, brow bone, waterline, nose, and Cupid’s bow. Compared to the Thrive Causemetics Brilliant Eye Brightener, which offers a more radiant finish, this pencil provides a more subtle, neutralizing effect that combats tired eyes without overwhelming the look. Its twist-up design with a built-in smudger makes application straightforward and mess-free, ideal for quick touch-ups. However, for those seeking a high-impact glow, it may require multiple layers, and its shade options are somewhat limited. This pick makes the most sense for users prioritizing longevity and a precise, natural highlight that stays put throughout the day.
Pros:- Long-lasting and waterproof, ensuring all-day wear
- Vegan and cruelty-free, aligning with ethical preferences
- Ease of use with twist-up design and built-in smudger
Cons:- May require multiple layers for intense brightness
- Limited shade options could restrict customization
Best for: Individuals needing a reliable, all-day brightener with a waterproof formulation, especially contact lens wearers or those prone to eye watering
Not ideal for: Makeup enthusiasts seeking a highly luminous or versatile highlighter that can double as eyeshadow, since this is more subtle and targeted
- Type:Highlighter Pencil
- Duration:8 hours
- Vegan:Yes
- Cruelty-Free:Yes
- Waterproof:Yes
- Dermatologist Tested:Yes
- Ophthalmologist Tested:Yes
- Safe for Contact Lens Wearers:Yes
Our verdict“This highlighter pencil is perfect for those who want a discreet, long-wearing brightening boost around the eyes and brow area.”
How We Picked
To determine the best eye highlighters, I evaluated each product based on performance, ease of use, build quality, and longevity. I considered whether the highlighter provided a noticeable brightening effect without creasing or fading, and if it offered good blendability across different skin tones. Price-to-performance ratio played a role, alongside factors like versatility and whether the formula is suitable for sensitive eyes. The ranking reflects a balance of these criteria, prioritizing options that deliver both glow and reliability for everyday wear and special occasions.| eye highlighter | Type | Finish |
|---|---|---|
| NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Jumbo | Eyeshadow, Eyeliner, Highlighter | Matte, Metallic |
| NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Jumbo | Highlighter Stick | Pearl |
| Thrive Causemetics Brilliant E | — | Shimmer |
| COLORGRAM Under Eye Highlighte | Highlighter & Contouring Stick | — |
| tarte Glow Wardrobe Highlighti | Face & Eye Palette | — |
| tarte Fake Awake Eye Highlight | Highlighter Pencil | — |
Factors to Consider When Choosing Best Eye Highlighters
Choosing the best eye highlighter involves several considerations beyond just the shade. Understanding your skin type, eye shape, and makeup style can help you pick a product that enhances your natural features. Here are key factors to keep in mind when selecting an eye highlighter:Texture and Formula
Eye highlighters come in creams, sticks, pencils, and powders. Cream formulas tend to blend seamlessly and provide a natural glow, but they may crease on drier or mature skin if not set with powder. Pencils and sticks offer more precision and portability, making them ideal for quick touch-ups, but they might require a good blending technique. Powder highlighters can be layered for buildable brightness but may emphasize fine lines if not applied carefully. Consider your skin type and application preference when choosing a texture.
Color and Finish
Cool-toned highlighters like icy whites or silvers brighten the under-eye area and help reduce shadows, making them popular for brightening. Warm shades, such as champagne or gold, add a subtle glow and work well on warmer skin tones. Matte or satin finishes are less reflective but can provide a more natural look, while highly luminous or shimmer finishes give a more dramatic effect. Think about your overall makeup style and the look you want to achieve when selecting a shade and finish.
Longevity and Wear
Durability is critical for highlighters intended for long days or special events. Some formulas are formulated with long-wear ingredients that resist creasing and fading, while others may require setting with powder or primer. Testing the product’s staying power on different skin types can prevent disappointment, especially if you need the glow to last through heat, humidity, or extended hours. Keep in mind that some highlighters may look excellent initially but lose their impact after a few hours.
Ease of Application
Application ease varies, with some highlighters designed for quick swipes, and others requiring more blending. Sticks and pencils are generally straightforward to apply directly to the skin, making them ideal for on-the-go use. Creams and powders might need brushes or fingers for blending, which can be more precise but also more time-consuming. If you prefer hassle-free routines, look for products with smooth textures and good blending properties to avoid patchiness or uneven glow.
Price and Value
The price range for eye highlighters varies significantly. While premium products often deliver superior pigmentation and longevity, budget-friendly options can still provide effective brightening if chosen carefully. Consider how much product you need and whether the formula justifies the price based on performance. Sometimes, investing in a slightly more expensive product pays off in terms of durability and overall appearance, especially if you wear highlighter frequently or for special occasions.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can eye highlighters be used on the brow bone or inner corner?
Yes, eye highlighters are versatile and often used on the brow bone and inner corners to open up the eyes and add dimension. Applying a small amount of highlighter to these areas can create a more awake and lifted look. However, choose a formula that blends well and doesn’t emphasize fine lines or creasing in these delicate areas. Cream or pencil formulas typically work best for precise application in these spots.
Are eye highlighters safe for sensitive eyes?
Most highlighters formulated for the eye area are tested for safety and are suitable for sensitive eyes, but it’s always best to check the ingredient list. Fragrance-free and hypoallergenic options tend to be gentler. Conduct a patch test before full application, especially if you wear contact lenses or have allergies. Choosing cruelty-free and ophthalmologist-tested products can also provide peace of mind.
How do I prevent eye highlighters from creasing or fading?
To prevent creasing, start with a clean, moisturized eye area and consider applying a primer designed for the eyelids. Using a light hand when applying highlighter and setting it with a translucent powder can also extend its wear. Avoid applying thick layers or over-blending, which can cause product to slide. Choosing long-wear formulas specifically designed for longevity can mitigate common issues like fading or creasing throughout the day.
Is it better to choose a highlighter that matches my skin tone or contrasts?
The best approach depends on your desired effect. Matching shades, like champagne or soft gold, tend to brighten without drawing too much attention, ideal for everyday use. Contrasting shades, such as icy or pink tones, can create more dramatic, eye-opening effects. Consider your skin tone, eye color, and makeup style to select shades that complement your natural features and the look you want to achieve.
How often should I replace my eye highlighter?
Most eye highlighters last between 6 to 12 months with regular use. It’s wise to replace products if they develop an odor, change in texture, or cause irritation. Using clean tools and storing the highlighter properly can extend its lifespan. Regularly inspecting your highlighter ensures you avoid eye infections or irritation caused by bacteria buildup or product degradation.
Conclusion
For those seeking the best overall highlighter, Thrive Causemetics Brilliant Eye Brightener offers a luminous, long-lasting glow suitable for most skin types. Budget-conscious shoppers should consider the NYX Jumbo Eye Pencil for its blendability and versatility, especially for quick touch-ups. If you prioritize luxury and premium quality, the tarte Glow Wardrobe Palette provides a variety of shades for different looks, making it ideal for makeup lovers who want variety. Beginners will find the tar Fake Awake Pencil easy to use, while those with sensitive eyes should look for products tested for safety. Each pick aligns with distinct needs, ensuring there’s a perfect option for everyone looking to brighten their eyes in 2026.
Fall Picks
fall essentials
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
